Where to Drink Guinness in Philadelphia Like You Mean It
You can technically order a Guinness most places in Philadelphia.
But drinking Guinness like you mean it? That’s different. That means you care about the pour. You respect the settle. You pick a bar that understands the ritual as opposed to one that treats it like just another tap option between a lager and a seltzer.
And while green beer on St. Patrick’s Day will always exist, a proper Guinness deserves better. Here’s where to go when you want to do it right.
Via Fergie’s Pub’s Google My Business
Fergie’s Pub
There’s something deeply satisfying about ordering a pint whilst at Fergie’s. The glass lands in front of you and the foam cap sits perfectly. On St. Patrick’s weekend, it’s shoulder-to-shoulder, but even on a random Tuesday, it still hits.
The Black Taxi
If you want your Guinness with neighborhood comfrot and zero pretension, The Black Taxi is your stop.
This pub has a strong local following, proper pours, and an easy going crowd that knows this place is the real deal.
Bonner’s Irish Pub
Bonner’s is one of those spots where Guinness feels like a tradition.
When you order one at Bonner’s, it doesn’t feel performative. It feels habitual. Like generations of Philly have stood at that same bar and done the exact same thing.
If authenticity matters to you, Bonner’s is the move.
O’Neals Pub
Guinness at O’Neals pairs well with the volume. You’ll be sipping while music pulses, while friend groups cheer, while the energy spills from room to room. It’s not a quiet pint — it’s a party pint.
The Black Sheep Pub & Restaurant
This one’s for the people who want their Guinness with a side of conversation.
The Black Sheep is for the people who want their Guinness without shouting over it.
Tucked into Rittenhouse, it feels comfortable and slightly understated. The seating encourages staying awhile, while the pint arrives looking exactly how you hoped it would. Sometimes the best pint is the one you don’t have to fight for.
If you’re planning to bar crawl this St. Patrick’s Day weekend, like Erin’s Express, make sure at least one stop includes a pint done right.
